Rory Best
Moderator: moderators
Rory Best
First time poster here.. So be gentle!
But is there anyone else thinking that Rory Best's days as 1st choice Hooker for Ireland are numbered? Brilliant as ever in the loose, but time and again for Ulster and Ireland (not to mention the Lions), he just has absolute mares with his throwing.
He had a number of opportunities with the Lions to stake a claim for the number 2 jersey but couldn't take it away from two other very mediocre team mates.
But is there anyone else thinking that Rory Best's days as 1st choice Hooker for Ireland are numbered? Brilliant as ever in the loose, but time and again for Ulster and Ireland (not to mention the Lions), he just has absolute mares with his throwing.
He had a number of opportunities with the Lions to stake a claim for the number 2 jersey but couldn't take it away from two other very mediocre team mates.
- Flash Gordon
- Leo Cullen
- Posts: 11703
- Joined: February 7th, 2006, 3:31 pm
Re: Rory Best
You almost hope that all the players best days are numbered because we have good players already and if the players coming in are even better that's outstanding! I like Best, again, he had a double digit tackle count yesterday, I think he's fantastic at the breakdown, is a massive on field leader and scrummages well. Sometimes his throwing is a little wayward but the same is true of Cronin. Think with Best, Cronin and Strauss we are very very well disposed at number 2. Joe has always been a Strauss fan, it'll be interesting to see what happens when he gets a run of games.
Flash ahhhh ahhh, he'll save every one of us
Re: Rory Best
Still the best hooker we have when everything is taken into account.
You know I'm going to lose,
And gambling's for fools,
But that's the way I like it baby, I don't want to live FOREVER!
And gambling's for fools,
But that's the way I like it baby, I don't want to live FOREVER!
- offshorerules
- Seán Cronin
- Posts: 3588
- Joined: October 19th, 2012, 1:51 pm
- Location: The Beverly Hills of South County Dublin
Re: Rory Best
I think his scrummaging ability also has to be taken into account and I know he's rated in that regard.
"POC will not be going to Toulon" - All Blacks nil » May 27th, 2015, 12:18 am
- simonokeeffe
- Jamie Heaslip
- Posts: 16777
- Joined: July 21st, 2011, 3:04 am
- Location: Dublin
- Contact:
Re: Rory Best
If he doesnt sort it out he will be dropped (for Cronin), thankfully we're not under EOS anymore
Retired from babbling. Can be found on twittter @okeeffesimon
Re: Rory Best
Is he though? I think I counted 4 (5?) lineouts lost on Saturday. Anytime he plays, I pray that's it's the best Best that plays, and not the one that can't throw straight or hit his man.
Don't get me wrong, the man is a fantastic leader, and animal in the loose but his bread and butter is lineouts, and whenever he's throwing I'm never as confident as I should be with a 1st choice hooker.
So if we agree that Cronin will either start on the field or the bench, does that mean it's between Strauss or Best.
Don't get me wrong, the man is a fantastic leader, and animal in the loose but his bread and butter is lineouts, and whenever he's throwing I'm never as confident as I should be with a 1st choice hooker.
So if we agree that Cronin will either start on the field or the bench, does that mean it's between Strauss or Best.
Last edited by WarPoodle on November 24th, 2014, 3:21 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Rory Best
I wonder if Joe ever looked at giving the throwing duties to another player - would be interesting to see if any of our props could throw
#LiveLifeLoveLeinster
#BeSeenBeHeardBeBlueBELIEVE
I'm a Book Mark and damn proud of it. Storm 1:08 forever
#BeSeenBeHeardBeBlueBELIEVE
I'm a Book Mark and damn proud of it. Storm 1:08 forever
Re: Rory Best
I've thought about this too but once you do that you're missing a very effective lifter in the line. Not point giving it to the row or flankers as the tend to be the ones going up for the ball. I believe back in the day it used to be wingers to throw the ball in but in the modern game you don't really want one of the quick lads tied up if the chance to spin it wide is there. I think this is the main reason hookers are throwers - short, slower than backs and not as strong as props.Xanthippe wrote:I wonder if Joe ever looked at giving the throwing duties to another player - would be interesting to see if any of our props could throw
Best tends to get better with a run of games so I'd be fairly confident in his throwing abilities come 6 nations time provided he stays fit.
Re: Rory Best
But if you use a prop to throw would you not replace him in the lineout with the non throwing hooker? I'd imagine Best and Cronin aren't far off being as strong as the propsjimbobjoe wrote:I've thought about this too but once you do that you're missing a very effective lifter in the line. Not point giving it to the row or flankers as the tend to be the ones going up for the ball. I believe back in the day it used to be wingers to throw the ball in but in the modern game you don't really want one of the quick lads tied up if the chance to spin it wide is there. I think this is the main reason hookers are throwers - short, slower than backs and not as strong as props.Xanthippe wrote:I wonder if Joe ever looked at giving the throwing duties to another player - would be interesting to see if any of our props could throw
Best tends to get better with a run of games so I'd be fairly confident in his throwing abilities come 6 nations time provided he stays fit.
#LiveLifeLoveLeinster
#BeSeenBeHeardBeBlueBELIEVE
I'm a Book Mark and damn proud of it. Storm 1:08 forever
#BeSeenBeHeardBeBlueBELIEVE
I'm a Book Mark and damn proud of it. Storm 1:08 forever
Re: Rory Best
Not so sure.. They're a good bit smaller than pretty much all the props involved with Ireland. Obviously this doesn't relate directly to lifting ability but for arguments sake it's probably a decent enough indicator.Xanthippe wrote:But if you use a prop to throw would you not replace him in the lineout with the non throwing hooker? I'd imagine Best and Cronin aren't far off being as strong as the propsjimbobjoe wrote:I've thought about this too but once you do that you're missing a very effective lifter in the line. Not point giving it to the row or flankers as the tend to be the ones going up for the ball. I believe back in the day it used to be wingers to throw the ball in but in the modern game you don't really want one of the quick lads tied up if the chance to spin it wide is there. I think this is the main reason hookers are throwers - short, slower than backs and not as strong as props.Xanthippe wrote:I wonder if Joe ever looked at giving the throwing duties to another player - would be interesting to see if any of our props could throw
Best tends to get better with a run of games so I'd be fairly confident in his throwing abilities come 6 nations time provided he stays fit.
Add this to the mess if you want to sub your designated thrower.. Does the present hooker now throw only to be subbed off again for a third thrower? It alters the continuity of the lineout too much and has the potential to create internal confusion. Direct swaps make sense in terms of roles and continuity on field.
- LeRouxIsPHat
- Jamie Heaslip
- Posts: 15008
- Joined: January 22nd, 2009, 7:49 pm
Re: Rory Best
Yeah I think it'd cause too much hassle but what you could do....is play a bit of a game for ten mins every few weeks where you test everyone's knowledge of the line out by just mixing up the players at random. That way you might see that someone has a talent for it and could step up in a crisis like Healy and SOB did in a game a few years ago.
- olaf the fat
- Seán Cronin
- Posts: 3636
- Joined: April 5th, 2006, 11:35 am
- Location: On the sofa of perpetual pleasure
Re: Rory Best
or just fit the radars like Donal Lenihan is always on about
As they say in Russia, Goodbye in Russian
- simonokeeffe
- Jamie Heaslip
- Posts: 16777
- Joined: July 21st, 2011, 3:04 am
- Location: Dublin
- Contact:
Re: Rory Best
going by interview with GT in IT O'Connell seems to be taking some of the blame on where he's calling the throws
Retired from babbling. Can be found on twittter @okeeffesimon
-
- Mullet
- Posts: 1259
- Joined: May 25th, 2009, 10:25 am
Re: Rory Best
A bit harsh I think. He had the a slight case of the yips at the weekend having not played in a while, but I'd still be happier with a yippy Best throwing instead of a normal Cronin. Cronin having a great day is better, but that is rare. Plus, Cronin is fantastic off the for impact - that should be his role for Ireland IMHO.
Declan Kidney is a incompetent, inept, provincially biased rugby dinosaur who is unfit to coach the Irish team.
(c) 2012 Dave Cahill
(c) 2012 Dave Cahill
-
- Mullet
- Posts: 1259
- Joined: May 25th, 2009, 10:25 am
Re: Rory Best
deflection i think, looks like poc is taking one for the team in public. in private i am sure that best will blame himself even if team mates and management don't - i expect he will be working even harder than usual on throwing as a result.simonokeeffe wrote:going by interview with GT in IT O'Connell seems to be taking some of the blame on where he's calling the throws
Declan Kidney is a incompetent, inept, provincially biased rugby dinosaur who is unfit to coach the Irish team.
(c) 2012 Dave Cahill
(c) 2012 Dave Cahill
- Dave Cahill
- Devin Toner
- Posts: 25515
- Joined: January 24th, 2006, 3:32 pm
- Location: None of your damn business
- Contact:
Re: Rory Best
I think O'Connell is just reflecting the reality that each instance of a successful lineout has at least three elements - thrower, receiver and supporter - and thats at its most basic level. If things go wrong its rarely the fault of one individual, and even when it is, there are things that can be done to alleviate that, increase the amount of banker calls, call a stunt line out etc until the unit confidence has been built back upberniemac67 wrote:deflection i think, looks like poc is taking one for the team in public. in private i am sure that best will blame himself even if team mates and management don't - i expect he will be working even harder than usual on throwing as a result.simonokeeffe wrote:going by interview with GT in IT O'Connell seems to be taking some of the blame on where he's calling the throws
I have Bumbleflex
-
- Mullet
- Posts: 1259
- Joined: May 25th, 2009, 10:25 am
Re: Rory Best
I think O'Connell is just reflecting the reality that each instance of a successful lineout has at least three elements - thrower, receiver and supporter - and thats at its most basic level. If things go wrong its rarely the fault of one individual, and even when it is, there are things that can be done to alleviate that, increase the amount of banker calls, call a stunt line out etc until the unit confidence has been built back up[/quote][/quote][/quote]Dave Cahill wrote:berniemac67 wrote:deflection i think, looks like poc is taking one for the team in public. in private i am sure that best will blame himself even if team mates and management don't - i expect he will be working even harder than usual on throwing as a result.simonokeeffe wrote:going by interview with GT in IT O'Connell seems to be taking some of the blame on where he's calling the throws
true, but the thrower will feel responsibilty whatever the talk is afterwards. if poc is acknowledging that his calling was off, this provides confirmation that there was a problem in one of those three elements.
the thrower only gets 100% reliable feedback from his input to the system when his throw is taken where it is intended. any other outcome and he doesn't know if his throw was accurate or not - even if there are other system failures identified.
PS - apologies for ballsing up the quotes here. edit won't permit me to fix them
Declan Kidney is a incompetent, inept, provincially biased rugby dinosaur who is unfit to coach the Irish team.
(c) 2012 Dave Cahill
(c) 2012 Dave Cahill
Re: Rory Best
Dave Cahill wrote:I think O'Connell is just reflecting the reality that each instance of a successful lineout has at least three elements - thrower, receiver and supporter - and thats at its most basic level. If things go wrong its rarely the fault of one individual, and even when it is, there are things that can be done to alleviate that, increase the amount of banker calls, call a stunt line out etc until the unit confidence has been built back upberniemac67 wrote:deflection i think, looks like poc is taking one for the team in public. in private i am sure that best will blame himself even if team mates and management don't - i expect he will be working even harder than usual on throwing as a result.simonokeeffe wrote:going by interview with GT in IT O'Connell seems to be taking some of the blame on where he's calling the throws
berniemac67 wrote:
true, but the thrower will feel responsibilty whatever the talk is afterwards. if poc is acknowledging that his calling was off, this provides confirmation that there was a problem in one of those three elements.
the thrower only gets 100% reliable feedback from his input to the system when his throw is taken where it is intended. any other outcome and he doesn't know if his throw was accurate or not - even if there are other system failures identified.
Yes it will....berniemac67 wrote:
PS - apologies for ballsing up the quotes here. edit won't permit me to fix them
-
- Mullet
- Posts: 1259
- Joined: May 25th, 2009, 10:25 am
Re: Rory Best
I'm even stupider than I thought I wasjohng wrote:Yes it will....berniemac67 wrote:
PS - apologies for ballsing up the quotes here. edit won't permit me to fix them
Declan Kidney is a incompetent, inept, provincially biased rugby dinosaur who is unfit to coach the Irish team.
(c) 2012 Dave Cahill
(c) 2012 Dave Cahill
Re: Rory Best
But no one likes a smart arse.