Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Moderator: moderators
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
It could happen but there's no specific reason to think that Rob Kearney won't be around next season.
He is as effective and as needed as ever. In fact he probably has less pressure from competition now at fullback than at any stage in his career: for Leinster and Ireland.
He is as effective and as needed as ever. In fact he probably has less pressure from competition now at fullback than at any stage in his career: for Leinster and Ireland.
-
- Leo Cullen
- Posts: 10988
- Joined: April 19th, 2017, 9:56 am
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Not sure about that, although he is still an effective player.ronk wrote:It could happen but there's no specific reason to think that Rob Kearney won't be around next season.
He is as effective and as needed as ever. In fact he probably has less pressure from competition now at fullback than at any stage in his career: for Leinster and Ireland.
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
He's definitely as needed as ever. I wouldn't fancy going into a big game without him at 15. Larmour is learning, but nowhere near the 15 RK is even at this stage.
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Definitely no specific reason, and he has said that he wants to continue [source: https://www.irishtimes.com/sport/rugby/ ... -1.3718791 ].ronk wrote:It could happen but there's no specific reason to think that Rob Kearney won't be around next season.
He is as effective and as needed as ever. In fact he probably has less pressure from competition now at fullback than at any stage in his career: for Leinster and Ireland.
But his place will come under an awful lot more pressure because there's practically no chance that he will be able to play another four years as an international and make the next RWC as a first choice 37 year old fullback. So it's not a case of if he goes [as it has been between the last RWC and the coming one], rather a case of when he goes.
The coaching change at international level will have a destabilising effect on his position in the national team, as will pressure from media and fanbase to start building a side for the next world cup.
He's an extremely high quality player though, and as has been said above, there's not a huge amount of genuine competition for his place at the moment - O'Halloran, Haley, Ludik and Larmour leading contenders.
- curates_egg
- Seán Cronin
- Posts: 3768
- Joined: November 29th, 2011, 3:50 pm
- Location: Brussels, Belgium
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
And Addison!hugonaut wrote:Definitely no specific reason, and he has said that he wants to continue [source: https://www.irishtimes.com/sport/rugby/ ... -1.3718791 ].ronk wrote:It could happen but there's no specific reason to think that Rob Kearney won't be around next season.
He is as effective and as needed as ever. In fact he probably has less pressure from competition now at fullback than at any stage in his career: for Leinster and Ireland.
But his place will come under an awful lot more pressure because there's practically no chance that he will be able to play another four years as an international and make the next RWC as a first choice 37 year old fullback. So it's not a case of if he goes [as it has been between the last RWC and the coming one], rather a case of when he goes.
The coaching change at international level will have a destabilising effect on his position in the national team, as will pressure from media and fanbase to start building a side for the next world cup.
He's an extremely high quality player though, and as has been said above, there's not a huge amount of genuine competition for his place at the moment - O'Halloran, Haley, Ludik and Larmour leading contenders.
I had high hopes for Keenan, but others seem less enthusiastic?
-
- Mullet
- Posts: 1766
- Joined: October 13th, 2014, 9:07 pm
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
If I remember didn't Kearney recently mention about maybe going to France after the RWC. I think a lot of people like me seem to think this will happen. Couldn't blame him if he does get a big paycheck before you finish up and spend time in a new country. He'd be a big asset for whoever signed him.
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
4 years is a high bar and there'll be a new coach in no rush to rebuild without key experience.
There are a few other positions with incumbents at ages where the next RWC will be a challenge. Many of those positions have understudies already.
The same questions aren't being asked as much of them. Larmour will be a better player learning off and competing against Kearney than if he's handed it. None of the other options are even close to him in positional sense and aerial threat.
I think it makes sende to keep him on a central contract.
There are a few other positions with incumbents at ages where the next RWC will be a challenge. Many of those positions have understudies already.
The same questions aren't being asked as much of them. Larmour will be a better player learning off and competing against Kearney than if he's handed it. None of the other options are even close to him in positional sense and aerial threat.
I think it makes sende to keep him on a central contract.
-
- Leo Cullen
- Posts: 10988
- Joined: April 19th, 2017, 9:56 am
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
there is absolutely no hope he will be kept on a central contract, which is why his current deal was signed up until the world cup.ronk wrote:
I think it makes sense to keep him on a central contract.
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
He'll be pushing 34 after the RWC, has a lot of mileage on the clock after coming through young, and has consistently struggled with injuries. Giving him another central contract post-RWC would be absolute madness.
"This is breathless stuff.....it's on again. Contepomi out to Hickie,D'Arcy,Hickie.......................HICKIE FOR THE CORNER! THAT IS AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
- Leo Cullen
- Posts: 10988
- Joined: April 19th, 2017, 9:56 am
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Back Three minutes this season
Jordan Larmour(11+0) = 866
James Lowe(11+0) = 820
Adam Byrne(10+0) = 800
Rob Kearney(8+0) = 544
Dave Kearney(7+1) = 542
Fergus McFadden(3+1) = 306
Hugo Keenan(3+0) = 199
Barry Daly(3+0) = 169
Jack Kelly(0+1) = 12
Jordan Larmour(11+0) = 866
James Lowe(11+0) = 820
Adam Byrne(10+0) = 800
Rob Kearney(8+0) = 544
Dave Kearney(7+1) = 542
Fergus McFadden(3+1) = 306
Hugo Keenan(3+0) = 199
Barry Daly(3+0) = 169
Jack Kelly(0+1) = 12
- Peg Leg
- Rob Kearney
- Posts: 9823
- Joined: February 1st, 2010, 5:08 pm
- Location: Procrastinasia
- Contact:
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
I'd imagine we will see Kelleher somewhere around the 400min mark at this stage next season.mildlyinterested wrote:Back Three minutes this season
Jordan Larmour(11+0) = 866
James Lowe(11+0) = 820
Adam Byrne(10+0) = 800
Rob Kearney(8+0) = 544
Dave Kearney(7+1) = 542
Fergus McFadden(3+1) = 306
Hugo Keenan(3+0) = 199
Barry Daly(3+0) = 169
Jack Kelly(0+1) = 12
"It was Mrs O'Leary's cow"
Daniel Sullivan
Daniel Sullivan
-
- Rob Kearney
- Posts: 8134
- Joined: April 10th, 2011, 10:23 am
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Certainly don't think that will happen. If I was trying to assess who we'ed use at Full-back for a RWC19 q/f, if RK got injured, it would come down to what team we were facing. If it was NZ, I'd probably opt for Addison. If it was S Africa, I'd play Stockdale - who played the majority of his under-age rep rugby in the position.neiliog93 wrote:He'll be pushing 34 after the RWC, has a lot of mileage on the clock after coming through young, and has consistently struggled with injuries. Giving him another central contract post-RWC would be absolute madness.
Larmour scares me at full-back thus far. He doesn't seem to take the position seriously enough. He is constantly looking for increased involvement. That is not a problem, if he understands that his primary role is organising the back three of the team. When he brings the ball up in a counter-attack, don't stay around for the next four breakdowns, get back in position and mind the house. Work on your kick and chase, so that opponents can't automatically assume you'll run the ball back.
Conway & Larmour (and even Addison) offer different dimensions to the full-back role than RK. But none of them are essentially defensively minded. Some people like that, I don't, my full-backs first responsibility is to mind our backs.
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Agree completely with the last sentence.Ruckedtobits wrote:Certainly don't think that will happen. If I was trying to assess who we'ed use at Full-back for a RWC19 q/f, if RK got injured, it would come down to what team we were facing. If it was NZ, I'd probably opt for Addison. If it was S Africa, I'd play Stockdale - who played the majority of his under-age rep rugby in the position.neiliog93 wrote:He'll be pushing 34 after the RWC, has a lot of mileage on the clock after coming through young, and has consistently struggled with injuries. Giving him another central contract post-RWC would be absolute madness.
Larmour scares me at full-back thus far. He doesn't seem to take the position seriously enough. He is constantly looking for increased involvement. That is not a problem, if he understands that his primary role is organising the back three of the team. When he brings the ball up in a counter-attack, don't stay around for the next four breakdowns, get back in position and mind the house. Work on your kick and chase, so that opponents can't automatically assume you'll run the ball back.
Conway & Larmour (and even Addison) offer different dimensions to the full-back role than RK. But none of them are essentially defensively minded. Some people like that, I don't, my full-backs first responsibility is to mind our backs.
Play it like that and you limit some of the attacking options available to the opposition.
It has been a key factor in Leinster's success.
Kick to RK and you've virtually no chance of getting the ball back.
His defencive reads also give our wingers more latitude in attack as well.
Mirror, Mirror on the Wall who's the greatest player of them all? It is Drico your majesty.
- riocard911
- Shane Jennings
- Posts: 6042
- Joined: July 27th, 2015, 10:42 pm
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Lots of talk in the Irish Rugby Shed on FB - based admittedly on one supposedly, according to themselves well-informed source - that Joe is going to start Henshaw at 15 vs the Charioteers. What would Leo, Stuart and Felipe think of that, were it to happen, I wonder...
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Henshaw is very capable of playing at FB but you'd think starting his FB career against the swingers is highly unlikely.riocard911 wrote:Lots of talk in the Irish Rugby Shed on FB - based admittedly on one supposedly, according to themselves well-informed source - that Joe is going to start Henshaw at 15 vs the Charioteers. What would Leo, Stuart and Felipe think of that, were it to happen, I wonder...
The last time he played FB was when he was playing for Connacht iirc.
Mirror, Mirror on the Wall who's the greatest player of them all? It is Drico your majesty.
- fourthirtythree
- Leo Cullen
- Posts: 10728
- Joined: April 12th, 2008, 11:33 pm
- Location: Eight miles high
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Henshaw was a temporary fullback filling in for injuries and retirement for a single season. He had one international game, for the wolfhounds, at fullback, where he was average.
Two talking points from down south are fairly constant: Kearney is no good and hasn't been since 2009, and Aki is better than Henshaw and he's really a fullback. He really isn't and that would be a huge gamble with actual fullbacks in the squad.
I wouldn't have a problem with Aki starting or Kearney not. But Henshaw at 15 would be a wild, wild selection.
Two talking points from down south are fairly constant: Kearney is no good and hasn't been since 2009, and Aki is better than Henshaw and he's really a fullback. He really isn't and that would be a huge gamble with actual fullbacks in the squad.
I wouldn't have a problem with Aki starting or Kearney not. But Henshaw at 15 would be a wild, wild selection.
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Wild is a bit of an understatement.fourthirtythree wrote:Henshaw was a temporary fullback filling in for injuries and retirement for a single season. He had one international game, for the wolfhounds, at fullback, where he was average.
Two talking points from down south are fairly constant: Kearney is no good and hasn't been since 2009, and Aki is better than Henshaw and he's really a fullback. He really isn't and that would be a huge gamble with actual fullbacks in the squad.
I wouldn't have a problem with Aki starting or Kearney not. But Henshaw at 15 would be a wild, wild selection.
Joe doesn't do that kind of nonsense anyway tg.
Mirror, Mirror on the Wall who's the greatest player of them all? It is Drico your majesty.
-
- Graduate
- Posts: 622
- Joined: May 18th, 2007, 9:54 am
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
If Leinster can't give him the gametime he needs at fullback, then the only option is for him to go to Munster...riocard911 wrote:Lots of talk in the Irish Rugby Shed on FB - based admittedly on one supposedly, according to themselves well-informed source - that Joe is going to start Henshaw at 15 vs the Charioteers. What would Leo, Stuart and Felipe think of that, were it to happen, I wonder...
- Peg Leg
- Rob Kearney
- Posts: 9823
- Joined: February 1st, 2010, 5:08 pm
- Location: Procrastinasia
- Contact:
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Probably move him TPFKM if he got a run of games thereriocard911 wrote:Lots of talk in the Irish Rugby Shed on FB - based admittedly on one supposedly, according to themselves well-informed source - that Joe is going to start Henshaw at 15 vs the Charioteers. What would Leo, Stuart and Felipe think of that, were it to happen, I wonder...
Edit: beaten to it by Enda
"It was Mrs O'Leary's cow"
Daniel Sullivan
Daniel Sullivan
Re: Leinster's Back Three options going forward
Robbie Henshaw - Starts by Team/Comp/Position
2012-13 [19 years old, Connacht]
Pro12: 2 starts @ No13, 12 starts @ No15
Heineken Cup: 6 starts @ No15
Ireland: 1 start @ No15
2013-14 [20 years old, Connacht]
Pro12: 8 starts @ No13, 9 starts @ No15
Heineken Cup: 4 starts @ No13, 2 starts @ No15
Ireland: 0 starts
2014-15 [21 years old, Connacht]
Pro12: 12 starts @ No13
Challenge Cup: 1 start @ No12, 4 starts @ No13
Ireland: 6 starts @ No12, 1 start @ No13
2015-16 [22 years old, Connacht]
Pro12: 4 starts @ No13, 4 starts @ No15
Challenge Cup: 3 starts @ No13
Ireland: 9 starts @ No12, 3 starts @ No13
2016-17 [23 years old, Leinster]
Pro12: 5 starts @ No12
Heineken Cup: 7 starts @ No12, 1 start @ No13
Ireland: 7 starts @ No12
Lions: 4 starts @ No12
2017-18 [24 years old, Leinster]
Pro12: 3 starts @ No12
Heineken Cup: 4 starts @ No12, 4 starts @ No13
Ireland: 1 start @ No12, 5 starts @ No13
2018-19 [25 years old, Leinster]
Pro12: 5 starts @ No12
Heineken Cup: 3 starts @ No12
55 starts @ No12 [27 Leinster, 23 Ireland, 4 Lions, 1 Connacht]
51 starts @ No13 [37 Connacht, 9 Ireland, 5 Leinster]
34 starts @ No15 [33 for Connacht, 1 for Ireland]
Last start @ fullback was for Connacht vs Munster [16/04/16], a 35-14 win in the Sportsground.
Lots of boring numbers there, headlines are:
- pretty much a No15 in his first season at Connacht [2012-13];
- split more or less equally between No13 and No15 in his second season [2013-14]
- No13 for Connacht and No12 for Ireland [2014-15]
- largely a No13 for Connacht but played some No15; largely a No12 for Ireland but played some No13 [2015-16]
- almost exclusively a No12 for Leinster, Ireland and Lions [2016-17]
- split time for Leinster between No12 and No13, played mostly at No13 for Ireland [2017-18]
- solely at No12 for Leinster, injured for November Internationals [2018-19]
2012-13 [19 years old, Connacht]
Pro12: 2 starts @ No13, 12 starts @ No15
Heineken Cup: 6 starts @ No15
Ireland: 1 start @ No15
2013-14 [20 years old, Connacht]
Pro12: 8 starts @ No13, 9 starts @ No15
Heineken Cup: 4 starts @ No13, 2 starts @ No15
Ireland: 0 starts
2014-15 [21 years old, Connacht]
Pro12: 12 starts @ No13
Challenge Cup: 1 start @ No12, 4 starts @ No13
Ireland: 6 starts @ No12, 1 start @ No13
2015-16 [22 years old, Connacht]
Pro12: 4 starts @ No13, 4 starts @ No15
Challenge Cup: 3 starts @ No13
Ireland: 9 starts @ No12, 3 starts @ No13
2016-17 [23 years old, Leinster]
Pro12: 5 starts @ No12
Heineken Cup: 7 starts @ No12, 1 start @ No13
Ireland: 7 starts @ No12
Lions: 4 starts @ No12
2017-18 [24 years old, Leinster]
Pro12: 3 starts @ No12
Heineken Cup: 4 starts @ No12, 4 starts @ No13
Ireland: 1 start @ No12, 5 starts @ No13
2018-19 [25 years old, Leinster]
Pro12: 5 starts @ No12
Heineken Cup: 3 starts @ No12
55 starts @ No12 [27 Leinster, 23 Ireland, 4 Lions, 1 Connacht]
51 starts @ No13 [37 Connacht, 9 Ireland, 5 Leinster]
34 starts @ No15 [33 for Connacht, 1 for Ireland]
Last start @ fullback was for Connacht vs Munster [16/04/16], a 35-14 win in the Sportsground.
Lots of boring numbers there, headlines are:
- pretty much a No15 in his first season at Connacht [2012-13];
- split more or less equally between No13 and No15 in his second season [2013-14]
- No13 for Connacht and No12 for Ireland [2014-15]
- largely a No13 for Connacht but played some No15; largely a No12 for Ireland but played some No13 [2015-16]
- almost exclusively a No12 for Leinster, Ireland and Lions [2016-17]
- split time for Leinster between No12 and No13, played mostly at No13 for Ireland [2017-18]
- solely at No12 for Leinster, injured for November Internationals [2018-19]